Rostra readers may have seen stories the last couple of days about the student military menbers at SDSU threatened with expulsion for not removing the U.S. flag from their balcony. We asked if anyone would be doing anything in their defense.
We thank the SDSU College Republicans for their quick response to that query, posted below.
Jordan Dennison, the SDSU chairman of the school’s CR chapter, additionally notes the following:
1) While the issue has been around for about a week, he found out about it Monday, and talked to the students themselves. They said they would only be expelled after multiple warnings to remove the flags. Monday night they said that they were keeping them up.
2) The next day (Tuesday), Dennison received texts saying the students were in trouble with the military for violating the military code of conduct for going to Channel 10 News.
3) They have since taken down all the flags as of Tuesday.
“As far as activism goes,” said Dennison, “there is not much we can really do but we will be passing out large American flags to be hung up on balconies in protest.”
That sounds like activism to us.
Guest Commentary
by Jordan Dennison, Chairman of the San Diego State College Republicans
Why is flying the United States flag on American public school college campuses an issue? Many students wonder the same thing at San Diego State University as two students, both members of the military — Junior Connor Fenwick, Army ROTC, and Sophomore Cameron Box, active duty U.S. Coast Guard — face disciplinary action and even expulsion for flying the American flag, an Army flag, the U.S. Coast Guard Flag and an SDSU blanket from their dormitory balcony. The reason that the school is directly related is because the students live in on-campus housing run by the school itself and so have to answer to the school and U.S. military.
But since when has flying the American flag and certain branches’ of the military flags been an issue on American college campuses? Doesn’t the First Amendment of the Constitution grant the “freedom of expression” to students to fly the flag of the country that they live in? A similar issue was had earlier this year at the University of California, Irvine where an Associated Students committee board voted to ban “Ol’ Glory” from the administration office under the nonsensical idea that the American flag was offensive and should be banned. This lack of logic has spread to SDSU where both students said that they were singled out for their patriotism as opposed to their peers who had foreign flags on their balcony, a British one for example, and other objects like towels draped over their balconies. America is a country of mixed cultures from all over the world and arguably the most diverse country on the face of this planet. As a College Republican and American, I am damn proud of this fact and am damn proud of the United States inclusion of other religions, cultures, and traditions.
Problems are bound to arise however, and questioning the place that the American flag has on public college campuses is the new big thing. San Diego State is by no means aggressive toward our service-members nor slandering of America and the American flag. SDSU is a proudly mixed-culture school and I am proud of this fact as well. SDSU takes great care of our student-veterans and military men and women and it is one of the many things I enjoy about this school. Yet, this is an unnecessary and uncalled for incident that should never have been an issue in the first place. This is obviously a case of two SDSU student-military peers being singled out, as none of their neighbors had the same issue. Nearby apartment complexes like BLVD 63, on the corner of 63rd Ave and El Cajon St., allow state and national flags to fly, so why not SDSU on-campus housing? The school claims that the flag flying violates the fire code but again, why don’t the Residential Advisors universally ask that everyone remove their objects off the balconies?
At SDSU, American flags are very common. You can walk into any given apartment or house and there is a significant chance that you will see an American flag proudly pinned to the wall. Hell, It is the same in my apartment! You will see the California flag, the same SDSU blanket, and the American flag pinned right above our living room T.V. It is common culture at SDSU for students to own and display the American flag, but God forbid it proudly be displayed outside for the public of the United States of America to see. Understandably though, if the flag flies near an open flame and is truly a fire hazard, then by all means please move that flag. Yet, even if the great flag of the United States of America caught on fire, it would probably be argued (as it has before) that setting the flag on fire is still a freedom of expression and wouldn’t have been an issue. But then again, God forbid young members of the United States military proudly fly non-burnt flags of the Coast Guard flag, U.S. Army flag, and flag of the United States of America outside for the world to see.
We hope and politely ask that SDSU change its on-campus housing code to reasonably allow state flags, national flags, and military flags, not just the United States flag, to be flown outside residents’ living areas.
Comments 7
You all are making this out to be a freedom of expression issue, or an anti American flag issue. This is neither. This is two entitled millennials who didn’t like the rental agreement they signed, so rather than do the adult thing and appeal the decision and try to have a policy discussion and change, they ran to the media. Now the College Republicans are doing what all Republicans do with non-stories like this, make it seem like they are victims and “liberal universities” hate America. Please. Grow up. These future military officers need to learn to follow rules and regulations and deal with the consequences when they do not.
In any case, given the PC ethos that already dominates so many campuses, stories like this are easy to believe.
“Two ‘entitled’ millennialis who didn’t like the rental agreement they signed…”
But their baby boomers grandparents, who staged “sit ins” were “honorable”.
They’re college kids- college kids resist against “The Man”. Today, “the man” is Karl Marx. Glad to see the young uns have some stones
FLY WHAT YOU WANT WHEN YOU OWN PROPERTY. WHO IS THIS SNIPPY YOUNGSTER, BRIAN BRADY?
ILL BET BRADY HAS NEVER SERVED IN A COMBAT ARM,NOR HAS CHILDREN.
AND WHEN I SAY OWNED PROPERTY ,I MEAN OWN. BRADY AM I ON TARGET?
SDSU is consistently lauded as one of the top universities in the country for serving veterans. They were the first university in the country to have a veterans house on fraternity row. They were one of the first universities in the country to have a student veterans organization. There veteran center was just given a larger space in the center of campus. They have a VA representative working on campus full-time. They just launched a veterans Ally’s program that teaches others on campus how do appropriately associate and deal with veterans and their specific issues. And they’re one of the only universities in the nation to have a war Memorial in the middle of campus honoring those alumni who gave the ultimate sacrifice for their country. And, they have dozens of academic programs, like troops to engineers, to serve our veterans. You all should be ashamed of yourselves for tearing down this institution that is so important to our region and does so much for our veterans, over this ridiculous issue of two kids who did not want to clean up their balcony.
And by the way, these two students claim to want to be military officers. Yet, they don’t understand how to follow rules, they don’t understand chain of command, and they do not know how to properly display the American flag. SMH
Maybe flags would be safe in an LGBTQA “safe zone”?
This is s simple matter of contract law and I’ve read the contracts involved. SDSU is right and the students are wrong. Protest the policy if you wish, but I would encourage the College Republicans at SDSU to choose their battles more wisely.