School vouchers gain ground — Wake up, California GOP!

Richard Rider, Chairman, San Diego Tax Fighters Richard Rider, Chairman, San Diego Tax Fighters 3 Comments


For me, the “wedge issue” that could reverse the dreary GOP appeal to minorities is school choice. It’s something I’ve championed for decades.

No single measure could better help minorities than offering everyone options to seek better educational choices for their kids. Democrat minorities understand and appreciate this option better than white suburban Republicans, but everyone would benefit — except, of course, the labor unions.

But what has been missed in CA is that school choice IS happening in a number of other states. In the Golden State, it’s like we’ve given up our kids’ future for the benefit of CTA and the other education labor unions.
It’s a concession that needs to change. The Democratic Party has chained itself to the unions — the GOP should commit itself to the parents, the kids and the taxpayers.

Here’s an excellent summary of a recent WSJ article on Louisiana’s remarkable education reforms — including though not limited to widespread school choice. It’s improving education options at both private AND public schools. And even a substantial number of Democrat LA state legislators have changed their thinking on this issue.

Given that this year President Obama is again proposing to ban the small D.C. school voucher program for poor kids, it’s an issue that the GOP needs to push to the front of the priority list.

And ,BTW, if you are not receiving the free daily email service from NCPA, you should sign up. Great summations of important articles and studies of interest to conservatives and libertarians.

NCPA Daily Policy Digest

Receive the Daily Policy Digest via Email

Education Issues

April 16, 2012

School Vouchers Gain Ground

The Louisiana state legislature has approved a new school vouchers system that, when signed by Governor Bobby Jindal, will be one of the largest in the country. The move caps 18 months of extensive expansion of voucher programs nationwide and broadens the national argument about the future of public education, says the Wall Street Journal.

With growing systems in Florida, Virginia and Indiana joining older programs such as those in Washington, D.C., and Milwaukee, Wisconsin, the use of vouchers has increased rapidly since 2010.

Nineteen states and Washington, D.C., have either voucher systems or “scholarship” programs that provide tax benefits to individuals and businesses for contributions that help pay for students to attend private school.

  • The vast majority of these programs are targeted at specific groups of at-risk students, such as low-income or those with special needs.
  • The Friedman Foundation for Educational Choice, an organization that advocates vouchers, estimates that about 220,000 students are currently enrolled in the programs nationwide.
  • The Louisiana program would add hundreds of thousands of students to the voucher camp, and would also implement several innovative policy provisions that would help put the program at the cutting edge of education.

John White, Louisiana’s superintendent of education, said the state’s current voucher program has saved money because the state spends about $8,500 a pupil to educate public-school students in New Orleans, but is spending only about $4,500 on average for voucher students.

The new system would expand voucher availability to an estimated 380,000 poor and middle-class students in low-performing schools.

Distinctly, the new vouchers would also be available for use by students to pay for state-approved apprenticeships at local businesses.

They would also be available to fund college courses and private online classes.

Opponents argue that the vouchers threaten to divert money away from cash-strapped schools, thereby threatening the educational outcomes of those who opt to stay in traditional schools. They also point to some studies that suggest that voucher students perform worse in key areas.

However, a study by Patrick Wolf, a professor at the University of Arkansas, that analyzed 10 voucher studies in seven cities found no evidence of harm to voucher students or those who opt to stay in public schools.

Source: Stephanie Banchero, “School Vouchers Gain Ground,” Wall Street Journal, April 11, 2012.

For text:


Comments 3

  1. Competition in education will drive costs down and quality up. There is only one problem with vouchers; they can distort the market. I’d prefer tuition tax credits but vouchers would certainly be better than funding the monopoly.

  2. Post

    Brian is correct — tax credits ARE a better option. The credits can be for paying for ANY kid’s education — perhaps through a fund — as it done in Arizona.

    But vouchers seem to be an easier concept for people to grasp — too many will wrongly assume that only the rich can take tax credits.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.